Number 29 (2014)

Wieczorkowska-Wierzbińska, G., Wierzbiński, J., Kumińska, A. (2014). Comparability of survey data collected in different countries

44 views Czerwiec 13, 2014 admin_a 0

Grażyna Wieczorkowska-Wierzbińska
Instytut Studiów Społecznych, Uniwersytet Warszawski
Wydział Zarządzania, Uniwersytet Warszawski
Wydział Psychologii, Szkoła Wyższa Psychologii Społecznej
Jerzy Wierzbiński
Wydział Zarządzania, Uniwersytet Warszawski
Anna Olga KuŸmińska
Wydział Zarządzania, Uniwersytet Warszawski

Abstract:
The incomparability of data collected in different countries is a major hindrance to cross-cultural research. We have focused our paper on the issues of measurement and sampling equivalence, as well as response styles manifested in the differences in the numbers of respondents choosing (i) „don’t know” and (ii) extreme responses, e.g. “definitely yes” or “definitely no”. To test cross-cultural differences we used an Italian and a Japanese representative internet samples, as well as data collected in both countries as a part of the International Social Survey Programme (1998, 2008). In almost all of the six question sets analysed, Japanese gave fewer extreme responses, and more “don’t know” responses than Italians. Results of this comparison are interpreted as an indication of the well known differences in the thinking styles (Nisbett, 2009), which in the Eastern cultures are manifested in the acceptance of contradictions (i.e., good and bad, strong and weak etc., exist in everything), whereas thinking in the Western cultures is guided by the law of excluded middle (i.e., a sentence is either true or false). Our analysis also highlights the necessity of detecting “false respondents,” who answer in a random fashion, and eliminating them from further analyses. Such false respondents are a bigger threat to analytical surveys directed at testing of relationships between variables than is a lack of representativeness of the sample, which is crucial when assessing the distribution of a variable in the population.
Keywords: measurement equivalence, response style, don’t know response, extreme response style, cross-cultural survey research, ISSP, false respondents

Cite this article as:

Wieczorkowska-Wierzbińska, G., Wierzbiński, J., Kumińska, A. (2014). Comparability of survey data collected in different countries. Psychologia Społeczna, 29, 128-143. doi: 10.7366/1896180020142901
Download original article (Open Access)
# File Type File Size Download
1 .pdf 267,26 KB wieczorkowska_et_al_ps_2_2014

Help us spread the news about this research!